Happy Thanksgiving everybody!
The farther you scroll down the deeper you get into our amazing selection of Christmas cheeses we have this year! We have ALWAYS appreciated every single one of you along this crazy journey and try our best to bring you the best quality cheese for a fair and affordable price. We’re all so excited to break open these beautiful pieces of cheese for you so you can lovingly share with your family at this wonderful holiday season. We hope to see you all in the coming weeks! From our family to yours! 🧀
**BE AWARE** *WE OPEN AT 9AM ON BLACK FRIDAY*
Holiday Preorders
**These are not sold on the website but may be pre-ordered starting on Black Friday by calling or visiting the shop directly. Pick up dates for the pre-ordered Christmas cheese are: Pick up dates for the pre-ordered Christmas cheese are: Thurs Dec 20th 9-8 | Friday Dec 21st 8-8 | Saturday Dec 22nd 8-6 | Sunday Dec 23rd 9-3 | Monday Dec 24th 8-3 | Orders End: Dec 15th**
By far Bill and Pat’s favorite! Expecting it to be creamy when served correctly at ROOM TEMPERATURE. Sweet flavor with nice crunch texturing from aging. Always surprises us with how amazing it tastes. Typically it’s never extremely sharp given its age which is why its always the most sought after.
An awesome beginner Christmas Cheddar. Still older than what we regularly carry but not as extreme as the 16, 17, or 20 year olds. Slight fruity taste, nice cheddar bite and flavor are to be expected!
Drier and sharper than an orange of the same age but still acquires a sweet, fruity top note. Amazing cheddar for its age.
Along the same lines as the 17 year but Wisconsin tends to taste a little sharper than New York, but still to die for!
Sharp bite with a more dry texture with a nice age crunch.
Typically the strongest tasting of our cheddars but don’t let it shy you away from the one if a kind flavor. This is one of Clayton’s favorites. Won Gold in the 1997 London International Cheese & Dairy Competition.
Soft and creamy. Still a milder blue flavor but packed with the “crunchies” you all know and love. Aging in the Pear Brandy gives it an amazingly unique flavor not come across often.
From what we’ve noticed it likes to get creamier as it ages which definitely does justice to the beloved complex and deep, rich flavor this English Stilton offers.
Nice caramel notes with a hint of almond lingering around the after taste. Always hard and a bit crunchy. Our best selling Manchego that some aging works wonders on.
Sharp, usually softens up a little after this amount of time which makes serving less if a hassle, great with some charcuterie.
We all knew this one was coming! Soaked 7-10 days in Remy Martin, this is ALWAYS a crowd pleaser. Mild sharpness, sweet flavor with low notes of Cognac. *if any other Christmas cheese is purchased in same order*
This blue is no joke! Typically a saltier, stronger creamy blue. With an extra year added it gets dark, crunchy, super creamy, and EXTREMELY tasty and strong. If you love cheese that fights back, this is right up your alley!
Email us
Call us
Facebook